audit finds weak spending reviews

Posted
Spending oversight lacking rigor

Austin city auditors found weak oversight of employee credit card spending in a new audit, covering nearly 1,600 cards and $45 million in fiscal year 2024-25. The audit cited insufficient reviews of card usage, outdated one-time training, and unclear purchase documentation as contributing factors, according to lead auditor Ashley Rodriguez.

The audit found Austin’s credit card program is significantly larger than those of comparable Texas cities, with nearly 1,600 individual cards issued in fiscal year 2024-25—almost double the total held by Houston, the next-highest city, according to Community Impact. Spending across those cards reached approximately $45 million, several times more than Fort Worth’s roughly $10 million. Direct financial comparisons with Houston and San Antonio were unavailable because Austin auditors could not collect that data, the report states.

The audit found Austin’s credit card program is significantly larger than those of comparable Texas cities, with nearly 1,600 individual cards issued in fiscal year 2024-25—almost double the total held by Houston, the next-highest city.

Austin Energy was excluded from the audit’s totals due to a card management system transition. The utility holds an estimated 237 employee credit cards and spent roughly $10 million in fiscal year 2024-25, according to the report.

Auditors identified three primary weaknesses in the city’s oversight process. Credit card activity is not closely reviewed to identify and shut down underused cards, according to the audit. The city requires only a one-time training session on credit card use, which auditors described as outdated and lacking thorough guidance; other cities require annual or biennial refresher courses. Additionally, documentation of purchases is often unclear, making it difficult to determine what was bought and why, and is not frequently reviewed for cost efficiencies.

The audit cited prior investigations into multiple employee spending abuses stemming from weak processes, including supervisory reviews. Lead auditor Ashley Rodriguez said the cases underscore the need for stricter controls. “These investigations highlight the importance of following all best practices to prevent fraud and misuse,” Rodriguez said.

The audit recommends shifting primary oversight responsibility to Austin Financial Services, rather than the current department-deferred system. Proposed improvements, all accepted by city management and expected to be implemented by fiscal year 2026-27, include annual reviews and revocation of underutilized cards, revising initial training and requiring annual refreshers, updating policies for clearer documentation and additional review levels, and analyzing all purchases annually for savings.

City finance officials confirmed updates are underway, and City Council members have requested implementation updates. Council member Marc Duchen suggested a follow-up report late next year to ensure the changes achieve the desired results.

Purchasing official James Scarboro noted that a $3,000 threshold for “small dollar, high volume transactions” can yield savings, but cautioned against overuse of the card system. “There’s a point of exceeding the benefit by having too many cards, using it too often, and you’re losing the opportunity for directing that to on-contract managed spend,” Scarboro said.

Auditors and finance staff said the report may not necessarily change overall credit card usage, which can reduce administrative burdens and costs. The city’s credit card program is designed to streamline purchasing for employees, but the audit concludes that without stronger oversight, the program remains vulnerable to misuse and inefficiency.

.

The post audit finds weak spending reviews first appeared on DAILY TEXAS NEWS.
News, Austin, Credit Card Oversight, Government Audits